Terry and Betsy Brennan collect round a laptop computer within the kitchen of their residence in Irvine, Calif., alongside their daughter, Chanel Brennan Brewster, as they log in to a Zoom assembly. They’re about to search out out whether or not their son and Chanel’s older brother, former Hawai‘i soccer celebrity quarterback Colt Brennan, died with continual traumatic encephalopathy, the degenerative mind illness introduced on by blows to the pinnacle.
Chanel, who’s a couple of months pregnant along with her second daughter, says she’s naming her after Colt—Marley James. Bob Marley was Colt’s favourite artist, and James was Colt’s center title. A framed jersey hangs on the wall beside them, commemorating Hawai‘i’s retirement of Colt’s No. 15.
Colt had been the most effective quarterbacks faculty soccer had ever seen. Throughout his junior yr at Hawai‘i, he set the NCAA single-season report for passing touchdowns with 58 and was projected to be an early decide within the NFL draft. He selected as an alternative to return for his senior yr in 2007, when he led the Rainbow Warriors to their first undefeated season and completed second in Heisman voting as Hawai‘i’s first finalist for the award. He completed his collegiate profession with 31 NCAA passing data.
Accidents and surgical procedures derailed his NFL career, nonetheless, and a automotive accident on a Kona freeway in 2010 left him with extreme and everlasting accidents that led to the top of his soccer profession. He struggled with alcoholism and addiction for a decade after that, out and in of numerous remedy and therapy packages, earlier than discovering Tree Home Restoration in Costa Mesa, Calif., in the beginning of 2021. He thrived because the Tree Home program built-in teachings on neuroscience and biology with writing alongside intense bodily coaching and challenges. The Brennan household felt like they’d the Colt they knew and cherished again.
However in Might 2021, Terry and Betsy returned residence from a visit to Mexico and located Colt drunk and excessive of their residence, having suffered a relapse. He was surrounded by bottles of vodka, cans of beer and canisters of nitrous oxide, one among his main medication of alternative. Terry drove him to Hoag Hospital in Newport Seashore, the place he was advised they had been holding Colt within the emergency room till he was capable of enter detox. As an alternative, Hoag launched Colt round 1 a.m. that evening, whereupon Colt made his method to a close-by motel. He apparently met some males who delivered numerous medication to him.
At round 4 a.m., responding to a 911 name, paramedics discovered Colt unconscious and never respiration from an obvious drug overdose. Colt was taken again to the hospital, the place he was in a coma and sustained by a ventilator and IV. When it turned clear the harm completed to his physique and mind was irreversible, Colt was allowed to die. He was 37 years old.
Post-mortem outcomes finally revealed Colt had died from the “mixed poisonous results” of ethanol, methamphetamines, amphetamines and fentanyl. However the Brennans wished to know extra—they wished to look deeper than the dependancy, to what may have been occurring in Colt’s mind to drive him into dependancy, and what could possibly be making it so onerous for him to get and keep sober. The Brennans donated his mind to Boston College’s CTE Heart to find out whether or not he had been affected by the illness, which might solely be recognized postmortem.
So now, on the opposite finish of Thursday’s Zoom name, Lisa McHale, director of legacy household relations on the Concussion Legacy Basis, and Dr. Ann McKee, a professor of neurology and pathology at Boston and the CTE Heart director, are able to share what they discovered.
McKee stated it was tougher than ordinary for them to look at the mind because of the nature of Colt’s dying. Because the drug overdose rendered Colt unconscious and unable to breathe for lengthy sufficient that his complete mind seemed as if it had suffered a big stroke, he misplaced loads of tissue that interfered considerably with McKee’s examination.
She additionally recognized important traumatic mind accidents in a number of components of his mind. The primary she famous was a large hole within the membrane that connects the 2 sides of the mind to one another. Colt suffered a major cavum septum pellucidum that ran the size of the membrane, which means there was a spot—or a cave—all alongside it that ought to not have been there. He additionally suffered a lack of tissue in his proper frontal lobe that basically left a gap there attributable to a considerable lack of tissue brought on by the 2010 automotive accident.
Whereas all of those components made it harder for McKee to evaluate the extent of CTE within the mind, McKee was nonetheless capable of verify Colt’s mind confirmed CTE within the frontal cortex, the mind stem and different subcortical areas. “It was sufficient to name CTE Stage I,” she says. “But it surely may’ve been larger had we been capable of actually assess different areas.”
The traumatic mind harm (TBI) brought on by the automotive accident alone would have been sufficient to create points for Colt, and the Brennans did see a marked change in his character after the incident. He turned extra emotional, and commenced ingesting and utilizing medication extra. Habit by nature hijacks brains and damages them in a means that convinces the mind it wants the addictive substance to outlive. This alone is usually an unlimited problem to beat.
Add in a TBI, significantly one to the frontal lobe, and that problem turns into magnified. CTE on prime of that creates a compounding impact. The prefrontal cortex governs govt operate and decision-making, in addition to the power to course of feelings in a wholesome method—and shut down his extra harmful impulses.
“His means to keep away from these issues was actually diminished,” McKee says. “He’s obtained impulses that he can’t management. He’s obtained urges which can be bodily in nature. There’s a bodily side to this. It’s not simply will. And fortitude. And self-discipline. He’s obtained accidents that he’s making an attempt to beat.”
Justin MacMillen, founder and director for Tree Home Restoration, says, “With that harm there, it simply made it that a lot tougher for him to develop into sober and maintain that sobriety, which is simply heartbreaking.”
“He was actually working uphill,” says Ryan Bain, a Tree Home counselor and former Division I faculty soccer participant. “He had a reasonably restricted toolkit given every thing he had been via with the automotive accident, the harm to his mind and dependancy in and of itself, with out all the different medical points. To not point out his fall from grace. It’s actually tough for folks, the conceit collapse that comes from that.”
MacMillen and Bain discovered it outstanding Colt was capable of get himself wholesome and sober contemplating all he was going through, particularly in mild of the CTE prognosis. In a journal, Colt wrote about how powerless he usually felt to cease himself from performing on the impulses that drove him again to ingesting and medicines repeatedly.
“Anybody combating that, they’re going to have an issue with all of these issues,” Bain says. “Consequence analysis. Having the ability to work via intense or aggressive tendencies which can be exacerbated. Planning. Rational decision-making. All of that. It simply turns into harder, extra complicated.”
Treating these points is an incredible problem, as nicely. “We actually want higher methods to assist these guys,” McKee says. “Higher methods to establish they’re going via these points. We all know this very nicely—that there’s virtually nothing to essentially provide these guys. There’s only a few those who even acknowledge this is a matter.”
Even whether it is acknowledged, “It is extremely tough to deal with.”
McKee says a method to assist folks affected by traumatic mind accidents and signs of CTE is to grasp precisely that: Their signs are the outcomes of accidents they’ve sustained and never reflections on who they’re as an individual. “Simply having that validation that it’s not willful, that it’s not a personality flaw, that it’s not a weak spot of his, that it’s not him—it’s truly this mind harm that’s very tough for everybody to handle,” McKee says. “That offers some consolation to folks, and it stops the self-blame.”
Though Colt modified considerably after the automotive accident, the science suggests the harm to his mind from CTE started years earlier. Terry recalled that Colt suffered a concussion whereas at Colorado as a walk-on earlier than he transferred to Hawai‘i, and, years earlier than that, when he was 12 years outdated, he suffered a concussion so extreme, he started throwing up and needed to go to the emergency room.
Nevertheless, whereas such concussions are actually a priority, McHale explains it’s the repetitive hits soccer gamers take which can be the true roots behind CTE.
“I didn’t understand that,” Chanel says. “I didn’t know that. So it’s not simply concerning the concussions.”
“It’s the continual hits,” McKee says. “These hits might be subconcussive in addition to concussive. It’s the cumulative nature of these hits to the pinnacle, which over time causes the mind to deteriorate. And he performed 17 and a half years, that’s a really very long time. And there’s substantial hits that happen on the youth stage of soccer. All of it provides up. … That’s why the deal with concussion, whereas very useful from the NFL, it’s not addressing the basis drawback. The basis drawback is the hits. Even those that the gamers play proper via as if nothing occurred.”
They do have an answer: “To actually make a dent, to mitigate CTE, you must cut back publicity. That means, the much less contact, the much less probability of growing CTE,” McHale says. “As a basis, we really feel very strongly that contact shouldn’t be launched within the sport of soccer earlier than highschool. That would go a great distance in decreasing the chance for a major variety of folks, and we’d see incidents of CTE lower considerably.”
After the decision, the Brennans thank McHale and McKee for his or her assist. They are saying they really feel extra peace now. They’ve a greater understanding of simply how a lot harm Colt was coping with and the way remaining sober was harder than anticipated.
Colt’s spirit lives on. The Brennans established the Colt Brennan Legacy Fund in Hawai‘i in an effort to present items and providers to folks there, in addition to contribute cash and sources to psychological well being causes in every single place. A shrine to him stays on a shelf in the lounge, on the middle of the family. A few of Colt’s ashes have been laid to relaxation at Pacific View Memorial Park alongside his beloved grandfather, whereas others had been unfold within the ocean on the household seashore home in Oceanside. On March 20, in a memorial ceremony open to the general public, the rest can be unfold within the waves off the coast of Oahu.
Betsy opens a scrapbook and begins leafing via it, one among a number of they’ve containing newspaper clippings and photos from all through Colt’s life and chronicling nearly each sport he ever performed.
The Brennans assume again to when Colt first started taking part in soccer. They understand he should’ve been not more than eight years outdated. “And,” Betsy says, “he most likely obtained hit so much.”
Extra School Soccer: