The Assertion
A broadly shared video claims that sleeping with herb-infused patches on the soles of your ft will rid the physique of dangerous toxins.
The Facebook video claims that utilizing Nuubu patches “might enhance your sleep high quality and general wellbeing – all inside a five-day detox course”.
The video particulars how “micro toxins” accumulate within the bloodstream and “trigger dangerous side-effects if much less untreated”. These purported side-effects embody poor focus, irritability, pores and skin issues, insomnia, weight achieve and complications.
It goes on to say the patches “naturally activate sweat glands and draw out dangerous toxins whilst you sleep with none discomfort”.
“Apply them to the soles of your ft earlier than mattress and get up to see years of constructed up toxins safely purged out of your physique in a single day,” the video says (at 2min 15 sec).
The footage options pictures of the patches turning black after use, which the narrator claims is proof they take away toxins.
On the time of writing, the September 13 video had been considered greater than 1.3 million instances, together with by New Zealand-based Fb customers.
The Evaluation
Whereas the concept adhesive foot patches or pads can rid the physique of poisons throughout sleep is very interesting, there is no such thing as a credible proof to assist the declare.
Nuubu’s website claims the foot patches are handled with vinegar, in addition to varied herbs, minerals and different dietary supplements. Nevertheless, consultants stated toxins within the physique are filtered out by the liver and kidneys and can’t be drawn out by a therapy utilized to the soles of your ft.
Professor Ken Harvey, from Bond College’s college of well being sciences and medicines, helped draft the World Well being Organisation’s ethical criteria for medicinal drug promotion and described the detox foot patches as “a profitable and well-known rip-off”.
He referred AAP FactCheck to an article by Steven Novella, a clinical neurologist at Yale University, which explains that toxins within the physique are filtered out by the liver and kidneys. It says foot pads merely change color because of the oxidation of chemical substances within the pad, not as a result of they extract toxins.
“You may’t actually take away vital toxins by the pores and skin, and many of the chemical substances you’d wish to take away are colourless,” the article says.
Prof Harvey additionally pointed to an article by Quack Watch, written by shopper advocate and retired US psychiatrist Stephen Barrett, which stated “the essential concept that toxins will likely be excreted by the pores and skin clashes with what is understood about human anatomy and physiology”.
“Sweat glands within the ft can excrete water and a few dissolved substances. Nevertheless, its minor position in ridding the physique of undesirable substances is just not modified by making use of foot pads,” the article says.
Prof Harvey lodged a complaint with the Australian Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) for failing to take motion on quite a few complaints about detox foot patches. Within the 2018 criticism, he stated the patches “don’t ‘detox’ the physique or take away toxins” or deal with medical circumstances and known as for “immediate regulatory motion”.
The TGA previously ordered an Australian firm to stop claiming foot patches can detoxify the physique or alleviate well being circumstances.
Equally, in 2010 the US Federal Commerce Fee equally banned a enterprise from promoting detox foot pads after it discovered claims the patches might take away toxins and deal with varied medical circumstances had been “false or unsupported”. The corporate was ordered to pay a $US14.5 million effective.
Brent Bauer, the director of the Mayo Clinic’s complementary and integrative drugs program, has written that “no scientific research have been printed that present that detox foot pads work or that they’re protected”.
He advised AAP FactCheck through e-mail that “there is no such thing as a proof of (foot pads’) efficacy primarily based on the requirements to which we maintain all medical remedies”.
A 2018 study printed within the Journal of Heavy Steel Toxicity and Ailments examined whether or not foot pads might take away metals from the physique. It analysed the presence of metals within the pads earlier than and after use in 53 individuals and located “no proof to counsel that detox foot pads assist promote the elimination of poisonous metals from the physique by the ft”.
An NPR investigation examined the same kind of foot pad in a lab and located the chemical composition of the pads was the identical earlier than and after use. The pads blackened after they got here into contact with any supply of moisture.
Berkeley University clinical professor of medicine James Seward has previously said the concept the foot pads draw toxins out by the pores and skin is “actually not very believable” as toxins had been eliminated by the kidneys and intestinal tract.
Prof Seward stated in an e-mail: “I’m not conscious of any peer-reviewed scientific research substantiating {that a} patch utilized to the soles of the ft can take away clinically vital quantities of poisons.”
University of Sydney dean of pharmacy Andrew McLachlan additionally advised AAP FactCheck “there is no such thing as a scientific foundation or scientific proof to assist these claims”, in reference to the Fb publish.
The video states the Nuubu pads had been invented by “Dr Hiroki Hiro at a number one hospital in Tokyo”, nonetheless AAP FactCheck was unable to search out any report of a Dr Hiro linked to the product. Nuubu didn’t reply to requests for touch upon the idea of its well being claims. Nubuu’s website lists the corporate as being primarily based in Lithuania with the merchandise shipped direct to prospects from China.
A number of articles have beforehand discovered no proof to assist the declare that detox foot pads take away toxins – see examples here, here and here.
The Verdict
There isn’t any credible proof to assist the video’s claims concerning the well being advantages of detox foot pads. Specialists have stated there is no such thing as a foundation to the suggestion they’ll take away toxins from the physique, whereas investigations by Australian and US regulatory authorities have discovered comparable claims about different foot pad merchandise had been both false or unsupported by proof.
False – Content material that has no foundation actually.
AAP FactCheck is an accredited member of the International Fact-Checking Network. To maintain up with our newest truth checks, comply with us on Facebook and Twitter.
